here are some reviews of "smelling trees" from critics and other publications.

def crew distro (distro is closed)
distro from alicia d.
what: distro from california
contact: aliciadee@gmail.com
"Sinoun is a very discriptive writer! There are four different parts to this zine. With this issue of Smellings Trees, the Sweet Relief series starts. This is a Story about a charater who has dreams within his dreams. The series Star Gazer is about a woman's experience of living in a world she has never been in: Planet Earth. When I was done with this story, I was so amazed, and I REALLY can't wait for the next part. This zine also includes Essays, Rants, "and/ or everything else." I was so into this zine, i didn't want it to end. The stories kept me wanting more. Without a doubt, this zine is one of the greatest zines I've ever read."

the die
edited by red roach press.
what: publication by "new readings in culture, literature, and philosophy"
specs: tabloid, 12 pages, free
contact: redroachpress@yahoo.com, po box 764, college park, md 20740
"smelling trees is a beautifully laid-out zine featuring fantastical writing and lots of strangely wonderful images. i know that's not a very clear description, but i can't think of any other way to put it. part of the problem, if you can call it that, is that smelling trees is unlike anything i've ever seen. it has this light, airy quality to it that makes it hard to categorize. i have a feeling, though, that that's just how editor sun noon likes it. as she says in her editorial, smelling trees "is for anyone in the world."
     anyway, the zine is divided into three parts: "SLEE" (or something like everything else), which consists of the usual fare--stories, rants, and essays; "sweet relief," which chronicles the adventures of a "dreamtraveler" who "lives in dreams"; and finally, "stargazer," which tells the story of a woman who finds herself "living in wich she's never been."

for the clerisy #65
reviewed by brant kresovich
specs: "good words for readers"
contact: po box 404, getzville, ny 14068-0404
"sinoun has posted the stories in this paper zine to the website at www.smellingtrees.com. the website is visually arresting but will send middle-aged astigmatics like me to the visine. the paper version has a distinctive design that even astigmatics can get into: newsprint, intriguing graphics, an attractive mix of handwritten and typed text, offest. articles are essays and fabulous fiction. price: $2 in the US but see the website for abroad prices and subs or write nuonis@gmail.com."

frenzy distro (distro is closed)
distro from joyous.
what: distro from california
contact: Joyous Ladi-FrEnZY, frenzydistro@gmail.com
"Reading "Smelling Trees" brought back this nostalgic feeling. The feeling I got as a child when I first picked up and read a book I really enjoyed. The feeling of drowning in simple, yet beautiful words and for a second you don't want to get out because for a second you're thinking this is way better than reality. "Smelling Trees" is a literary zine that contains pieces about a girl reuniting with an old friend, about a woman who is isolated on an island with no contact(who wants no contact), And there are some pieces in journal entry form. She writes about the simple things that we all love, well, most of us at least. Can't wait for the next issue! "

katie (with the la la theory - distro)
reviewed by katie
specs: distro and zine writer!
contact: website
"smelling trees is filled with some really interesting stuff, all written by Sinoun, and her photography, layout and design are modern and pretty. I’m tempted to call her fiction experimental, but that might be misleading. It’s really just very imaginative, which is what fiction is supposed to be, right? One of my favorite pieces is a one-page genderfark called “superhuman,” told from the perspective of a little girl taking the train with her mother. "everyone looks sad or mad," the girl thinks to herself. “i can’t tell.” Fantastic. There are 8 stories and 3 titled visual pieces with other artwork throughout."

mae undead
reviewed by mae undead for gimme brains!!! distro
specs: distro
contact: website
"After putting this zine down, I was stuck in some trance. Sinoun writes with vivid details that I keep begging for! She has her stories divided into three different sections: SLEE (Something Like Everything Else), Stargazer, and Sweet Relief. A lot of passion, imagination, strained eyes came out of this project. Sometimes I couldn't read the text although I still understood the point that was going across. I don't have many words to express what this zine represents but it is truly lovely."

maximum rock n roll
reviewed by mrr
specs: magazine
contact: website
"smelling trees is the work of a person named sinoun of suwanee, georgia. visually, smelling trees has a pretty cohesive look. it's black and white, with small, simple print, and some handwritten text at the beginning and end. my favorite things about it were the images peppered throughout the zine, some of which were superimposed by text. the images consisted of trees and faces, starscapes, and animals. trippy? umm, yes, as is the writing. it's all very emotional and dreamy and arty, but i imagine it will find an audience. if you're currently experimenting with psychedelics, or would like to read a story in which trees and the characters named "the dreamer" are prominently featured, this zine may be for you."

newpages.com
reviews by sean stewart
specs: online reviews
contact: website, newPages, PO Box 1580, Bay City, MI 48706
"Another respectable first issue, Smelling Trees offers fiction, both realistic and science, and some nice black-and-white photography in a classy newsprint digest format. The first story was pretty good; it had an authentic first-person voice. My favorite piece was 'The Writer Who Does Not Read,' which has this whole fictitious historical background built up around it...very convincing and entertaining. Sinoun plans to continue this story, which I think is a fine idea, as it seems ideal for serialization. The science fiction didn’t appeal to me, not that it wasn’t written well because I think it was decent, but because my taste in this genre runs really narrow. I enjoyed the photos, especially the collage near the middle of the zine, which also has some intriguing bits of prose scattered through it. This is free, so you have no excuse not to drop Sinoun a line and request a copy. Definitely a well-produced first effort. "

slug and lettuce
edited by christine.
what: publishing, "a zine supporting the DIY ethics of the punk community"
specs: tabloid size, 20 big pages, $free
contact: christine, po box 26632, richmond, va, 23261-6632
"you've just gotta love the newsprint zine! it leaves an impression on your mind and on your fingers (and sometimes around the house, as well!) hailing from suwanee, ga smelling trees is an interesting collection of unique short fiction stories, arty photos, teeny tiny fonts and a nice headshot xerox. within these pages you can quit your job, get reacquainted with an old friend, get hit by a car, be superhuman, ponder 'the writer who does not read', contemplate the lovely heads project, and follow the stargazer. have i peaked your interest? then send for your copy today! nice work." (--karoline)

the thought
edited by ronald c. tobin.
what: "philosophers guild"
specs:full size, 28 pages, $2
contact: guildmaster@worldnet.att.net, po box 10760, glendale, az 85318-0760
"a very attractive little zine published by sinoun. besides the excellent visuals, the articles are quite interesting, among them was "seven fifty nine." i hope to see more of this zine in the future.

roctober
edited by jake austen.
what: zine/magazine
specs:full size, 96 pages, $4
contact: 1507 east 53rd #617, chicago, il 60615
"at first i was a little put off by sinoun's use of circles to dot the letter "i" in his handwriting (this offset personal zine uses a variety of layouts, mixing handwriting with small, legible font for an effective visual mix). but once i got past that i really was swept up in his world and his sensitivities. unlike a lot of personal zines this isn't merely a journal but almost a literary exercise, as this is definitely about the art of writing as much as the means of expression."

the guy thought i was a dude! haha! sometimes people briefly read what i write and they think this is more of a perzine than a litzine.

xerography debt #19
reviewed by maynard welstand
specs: zine review zine
contact: davida, po box box 11064, baltimore, md 21212
"short stories with lesbian or gender bending themes with a zen-like, philosophical spirit and highly effective stream of consciousness narrative style. stories run the gambit from reunited friends with a sudden death, historical fictional lesbian writers, to an alien in a botched mission. stories are told with a noteworthy skill in a tone that is compelling, mysterious, and sometimes zen. graphic design is great with a thrifty use of newsprint. if the other issues are like the one i read, this is worth a subscription. sinoun should branch out into novelistic prose, she has the skillz."

xerox #10
edited by shaiful.
what: zine
specs: ?
contact: trashkore@yahoo.com, shaiful, Blk 554 Bedok North St 3, #08-241 Singapore 460554, SINGAPORE
"OK a personal zine. I have, of course, no problem with personal zines. They are good and offer an insight to someone else's world. They create a bridge yet is far from intrusive. However, reviewing them is another story. A justified review would take a page and I don't have the capacity to practice that, even more so when this reached me just a day before I began the review section. Written by a girl Sun Noon, this zine is segmented into 3 parts, to frame up different moods. 2 of fantasy and 1 of semi-fantasy (rants and such). I like the presentation (short, yet detailed) and look of this zine, as well as the photos. Even her introduction and endnote seem to blend in with her beautiful handwriting. A window to someone's thoughts, anyone?"

zine world #22
reviewed by artnoose and mishap
specs: "a reader's guide to the underground press"
contact: jerianne@undergroundpress.org
"Artsy, literary personal zine chock full of 8 point type superimposed over really nice black and white photos. Although this made it somewhat hard to read, the technical design skill was commendable. She uses a lot of dream imagery, which made some of the stories kind of inaccessible to me; I felt like they were just in her head, and I didn't have any way to relate." [:15] --artnoose.
SECOND OPINION: "Sinoun's fiction zine, with photographs, is printed on newsprint. While text over photos made it hard to read in some parts, the stories are pretty good. One reads like a journal/personal zine piece about a woman's day, running into an old friend and falling for her. In another, she invents an eccentric, mysterious author and the text of the person who went to find her. Creative zine I'd like to see keep going." [:35] --mishap.

zine zine #3
reviewed by gunter
specs: its all in german. i don't know german, do you??
contact: ??
"Das Heft habe ich über eine Internet-zineaus- tauschgegen- seitigbeglückentotal-glücklichmachenseite bekommen und natürlich ist es eines von der Sorte, die ich mir sonst nicht gekauft hätte (da ich eben kaum Geld habe im Moment) und die dann doch den Horizont etwas erweitern. Es gibt Kurzgeschichten, die für mich natürlich nicht einfach zu verstehen sind, da mein Englisch das mieseste diesseits des Äquators ist. Au?erdem bekam ich noch ein nettes Schaf gezeichnet (es geht hier nicht um Punk)." [review by gunter]